|
By Steve Stroh [1]
Note to the reader this article is not
intended to be "deeply technical"; it is
offered as a readable, reasonably complete overview
of the unique aspects of the AllCoNet2 / CONXX Platform
Network to readers with some technical background
and some exposure to networking and broadband wireless
technologies.
And then the telephone company representative said
"We're sorry, but our lawyers tell us that if we
allowed Allegany County to pay us to install an ATM
switch, we'd have to do the same for every community
that wanted one."
Sometimes, the most profound innovations spring from
the most unlikely circumstances, and that is the case
with the above conversation giving rise to AllCoNet2
in Allegany County, Maryland, which in turn has given
rise to cost-effective, carrier-grade networks based
on CONXX Platform technology potentially being deployed
anywhere in the world as primary telecommunications
infrastructure.
AllCoNet2 came to life [2]
in a rural Maryland County that badly needed new jobs.
Allegany County had done all the right things and
had attracted several companies to seriously consider
locating new facilities there, which included a significant
number of new jobs. All of the prospective companies'
"checklist" items had been satisfied, except
one adequate telecommunications infrastructure.
The conversation that opens this article was the end
result of a long series of conversations between Allegany
County officials and the local telephone company.
AllCoNet2 was created to provide that "refused"
new telecommunications infrastructure for Allegany
County, and it has been very successful. AllCoNet2
satisfies both new (Internet) and legacy (T-1, T-3)
telecommunications requirements of businesses and
is providing innovative new services such as Open
Access Broadband Internet Access, Public Safety Mobile
Broadband, as well as being an extremely cost-effective
telecommunication backbone for public agencies such
as the local library system, school system, and county
government.
When other government agencies began to find out
about AllCoNet2 and what it was doing for Allegany
County, they asked Allegany County to help them build
similar networks. That was not feasible county
governments aren't in the business of building telecommunications
networks for other government entities. There were
a number of unique, very valuable technologies developed
as part of AllCoNet2, and it was decided to find a
private company to be a "Technology Transfer
Partner"; CONXX Inc. of Salt Lake City, Utah
was selected. The technologies developed as part of
AllCoNet2, and follow-on technologies developed and
funded by CONXX, comprise the CONXX Platform [3]
the means by which CONXX Inc. can build additional
"AllCoNet2 Networks" for government agencies,
private companies such as Competitive Local Exchange
Carriers (CLECs), or even telecommunications carriers
that need more cost-effective solutions to extend
their networks into new areas.
Understanding the CONXX Platform [4]
is akin to peeling an onion and unless you peel down
through all the layers, you don't get anywhere near
a complete picture of what the CONXX Platform really
is, or its profound implications for the future of
telecommunications. Previous articles that have been
written about AllCoNet haven't really done justice
to the bigger picture of the CONXX Platform. To date,
the only way to get "up to speed" on AllCoNet2
/ CONXX Platform is to visit Cumberland, MD and see
AllCoNet2 for yourself. When asked how long presentations
take, CONXX personnel joke, "we've been able
to get the short version down to one day."
Wireless
Cost-effective Allegany County encompasses
525 square miles of the Northwest corner of Maryland
in the foothills of the Appalachian Mountains. Allegany
county is mostly rural (population 75,000), except
for the city of Cumberland (population 21,500). The
cost of deploying a new fiber-optic communications
network that would reach the majority of citizens
and businesses of Allegany County was estimated to
be $680 million. In contrast, the cost of a wireless
network that would meet the immediate telecommunications
requirements of Allegany County and be scalable to
future requirements was $4.7 million.
CONXX Platform Networks embody all of the primary
features and services of a modern telephone company
[5]. Three different
types of wireless systems are used in the CONXX Platform:
- Very high capacity point-to-point links that
form the "backbone" of a CONXX Platform
network.
- "Medium capacity" point-to-multipoint
links that connect individual premises and the CONXX
Platform network.
- "Last few feet" links inside a premises
or localized area, typically using Wi-Fi.
It's important to note that the use of wireless in CONXX
Platform Networks is very different from the use of
wireless by Wireless Internet Service Providers (WISPs).
WISPs typically are only able to provide a "best
effort" grade of service; a CONXX Platform Network
offers very high reliability and integrates numerous
Quality Of Service (QOS) mechanisms in order to deliver
true carrier-grade services and reliability.
ATM Core
Reliability, All Telecom Services The
core of a CONXX Platform network is the use of Asynchronous
Transfer Mode (ATM) to "move the bits".
ATM isn't discussed much outside of telephone companies
and for good reason ATM was designed around
the needs of telephone companies:
- Compatibility with previous generations of telephony
voice and data networks
- Scalability
- Quality of Service
- Reliability
- Security / absolute separation of data flows
With ATM at its core, the CONXX Platform isn't "just
as good as" a telephone company's services, a
CONXX Platform Network provides the same services
as a telephone company. For example, T-1 links are
the most typical type of data network connection between
a large business and its branches, such as a bank.
The telephone company installs, maintains, monitors,
and repairs the T-1 connections. A T-1 has distinct
electrical and network characteristics that can be
emulated by other network technologies, such as Ethernet-over-wireless
systems... but such "emulations" have often
proven to be problematic. While a CONXX Platform Network
T-1 connection is wireless, care is taken to provide
exactly the same characteristics as a T-1 line that
businesses expect electrical compatibility,
and most importantly full signaling compatibility
through the CONXX Platform Network because of the
use of ATM (just as in a telephone company). This
"full compatibility" also applies to "bigger"
links such as T-3/DS3 service (45 Mbps).
Scalability
One of the primary reasons for the use of ATM is scalability;
it would be the worst of all possible worlds if a
new network were to be used so intensively as one
could possibly hope... to the point where a new network
is required because too much demand saturated the
previous one. ATM allows scalability on a massive
scale, far in excess of what could conceivably be
needed in single network. When additional capacity
is needed in a CONXX Platform Network, another node
is simply added to the network, and the overall capacity
is thus increased as more last-mile(s) links can be
accommodated. This probably sounds ridiculously simplistic,
but it really does seem to be the case that with ATM,
it is that simple; there is no point of diminishing
returns as with other network systems beyond which
performance issues make it difficult to scale.
Last-mile(s) Agnostic
Use what equipment makes sense
Broadband Wireless Internet Access (BWIA) isn't exactly
a new business. It's been tried in one form or another
for more than a decade, with varying degrees of success.
One constant has emerged in BWIA continuous
evolution of equipment. Of late, that means WiMAX.
Even in WiMAX, which was supposed to be all about
"standards" providing some certainty to
equipment choices for BWIA deployments, disruptive
evolution has occurred in the development of "Mobile
WiMAX"... even before interoperability tests
had been completed for "older" (by perhaps
one year) "Fixed WiMAX" systems.
To allow for such evolution, the CONXX Platform only
"loosely couples" the last-miles(s) portions
of the network to the other elements of the network.
It is quite possible to operate multiple types of
last-mile(s) equipment, simultaneously, in the same
CONXX Platform Network. If a customer has a preference
for a particular vendor, as long as certain basic
requirements largely relating to the overall quality
of the system are satisfied, it is likely that the
customer's system preferences can be accommodated
in their CONXX Platform Network.
This Last Mile Agnosticism extends even to the use
of wireless last-mile(s) links being optional. The
CONXX Platform is inherently "fiber-ready"
all key elements of the CONXX Platform can
accommodate fiber as an alternative to wireless links.
This capability is expected to be particular useful
CONXX Platform Networks deployed in urban areas where
fiber is sometimes available for use.
(To a lesser extent, the "loosely coupled"
philosophy also applies to the "core" of
the CONXX Platform multiple backhaul radio
vendors can be accommodated.)
Security
Separation Of Data Flows
One of the primary reasons that ATM was
chosen for the core of CONXX Platform Networks was
the ability to rigidly segregate data flows from different
user populations within the CONXX Platform Network...
just like the telephone company has to do. This capability
is called Soft Permanent Virtual Circuit (SPVC) and
that capability allows a common, reliable, "expensive"
network to be built, while effectively servicing a
diversity of customers and types of customers, and
rigidly keeping each customer's data flows completely
separate other customer's data flows. This allows
a CONXX Platform Network to be used for public safety
and commercial customers. SPVC also makes possible
the Open Access model for allowing multiple Internet
Service Providers to use a common CONXX Platform Network
(more about Open Access model below.) "Soft"
PVC is an intriguing capability it allows dynamic
allocation of available network bandwidth and prioritization.
This capability could be used in an emergency when
public safety users of a CONXX Platform Network need
much more the network's bandwidth than normal in order
to provide communications from the scene of a disaster.
Management
All Elements
While telephone companies can afford entire
staffs devoted to monitoring and managing their networks,
CONXX Platform Networks are, again, designed to be
cost effective, so monitoring and managing a CONXX
Platform Network has been streamlined to automate
the management, monitoring, and troubleshooting of
problems in a CONXX Platform Network. The CONXX Platform
Network Management System (NMS) was written from scratch
and allows one person... or a staff... to manage and
monitor a CONXX Platform Network. (Text does not come
anywhere close to describing the intuitiveness of
the CONXX NMS even a static photo would not
do it justice. It is truly intuitive and easy to use.)
The CONXX Platform NMS is relatively unique
it is not based on other NMS systems such as HP OpenView
and CA SPECTRUM. Each element that is part of a CONXX
Platform Network is intensively monitored, its behavior
characterized over time, trends recorded, and can
be individually monitored, isolated, and controlled
in a few seconds and a few mouse clicks... down to
the usable life cycle of a battery in an individual
Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS), the fuel level
in the tanks for backup generators, and the outside
temperature at a CONXX Platform Network tower site.
Quality Of Service
Across Network Elements
Not only must a CONXX Platform Network
offer the same services as a telephone company to
fulfill its role, it must be able to deliver those
services at the same Quality Of Service level(s) as
a telephone company. Not just reliability (and again,
that will be deferred for discussion below) but reliable
flow of data throughout the network far better
than the "best effort" grade of service
that is typical for not only WISPS using wireless,
but also Digital Subscriber Line (DSL) services from
the telephone company and cable (television) modem
service. While QOS isn't an issue within the ATM core
of a CONXX Platform Network... (QOS isn't "added
in" to ATM; it's inherent; packets simply don't
get dropped in ATM networks as there is no "contention".
If packet loss does occur in an ATM network, it's
a major failure mode and redundant network elements
are brought online to correct the error.)
... Ensuring effective QOS is very much an issue
in the "last mile" and "last few feet"
wireless links that are used in a CONXX Platform Network,
which are typically based on Ethernet technologies,
and thus subject to packet loss which could result
in degraded Quality Of Service. In designing a CONXX
Platform Network, measures are taken to minimize the
possibility of "external" packet loss
link lengths are kept short to insure reliable link
margins, the radios used in a CONXX Platform Network
are high-quality and use robust modulation technologies.
Most carrier / enterprise-grade "last mile"
and "last few feet" radios have their own
QOS mechanisms and may incorporate and interoperate
with Ethernet-based QOS mechanisms such as Multi-protocol
Label Switching (MPLS). But the radio's QOS mechanisms
don't interoperate (cleanly) with ATM, so CONXX developed
a proprietary "multiprotocol encapsulation bridge"
(MEB) device to insure QOS is maintained in the transition
between the ATM core of the CONXX Platform Network
and the last mile(s) wireless link. The overall result
is far better QOS performance than what was possible
with just the "radio's" QOS mechanisms.
The "MEB" approach was chosen instead of
using... or having to build... ATM-based last mile
wireless links. A goal of CONXX is to be "agnostic"
in the choice of last-mile connectivity, even to the
extent that radios are optional when it's more expedient
to use fiber between a CONXX Platform Network node
and network users. While the work to qualify and integrate
a particular last-mile(s) wireless link into the CONXX
Platform isn't "easy", neither is it "difficult",
and thus new last-mile(s) wireless links and technologies
can be used as new solutions when needed, such as
making use of WiMAX systems when such systems are
more available, mature, truly interoperable, and cost-effective.
Open Access Model
Many organizations, one network
"Open Access" the ability
of multiple organizations to share the usage of a
single network is a controversial concept. Cable television
companies have traditionally been exempt from Open
Access requirements. Until very recently, telephone
companies were subject to Open Access requirements
such as allowing ISPs to lease "Unbundled Network
Elements" (UNEs) to provide DSL service. Recent
changes in telecom law have rendered Open Access across
telephone company networks somewhat moot.
To customers, Open Access is a powerful concept,
allowing them the best of both worlds their
choice in services that fit their specific needs,
with the reliability and cost-effectiveness of the
construction, sharing, and maintenance of a single
well-maintained, well-financed network.
In a CONXX Platform Network, Open Access allows a
number of Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to connect
customers to a CONXX Platform Network. The ISPs use
the same type of radios (only models of radios "certified"
for use with CONXX Platform networks), they can even
connect the radios to the same network node, but the
data flows for each ISP throughout the CONXX Platform
Network are kept completely separate. CONXX charges
a modest fee per customer for use of the CONXX Platform
Network, and the individual ISP is free to charge
as little, or as much for their services to their
customers as they wish. The benefit to the ISP is
that the CONXX Platform Network is "paid for"
and "fully deployed" they can spend
all their time marketing to and "plugging in"
customers and the "back end" of the CONXX
platform Network is handled by others.
Each CONXX Platform Network ISP is granted access
to the CONXX Platform Network Management System (restricted
to monitoring and managing only the customers on "their
segment" of the CONXX Platform Network.)
Open Access is a feature of a CONXX Platform Network.
Implementing Open Access is completely optional to
accommodate buyers of CONXX Platform Networks that
intend to use a CONXX Platform Network entirely for
private purposes.
But implementing Open Access is a powerful tool for
economic development, and making it available on a
government owned-and-built network has some significant
advantages:
- It dilutes the oft-cited argument that "governments
shouldn't be building networks" and "taking
away business from private ISPs.
- Multiple ISPs can provide service in a community
in direct competition without "ruinous"
competition for scarce license-exempt spectrum (or
providing access to expensive licensed spectrum).
- By direct, or indirect involvement, Government
can insure that a tier of Broadband Internet Access
is made available and affordable to those that could
benefit from it most such as the poor and the home-bound.
- Government networks can be built to provide coverage
to all areas and citizens, not just those affluent
areas that provide a quick Return On Investment
(ROI).
Open Access
Taking it one step further
While not yet complete, CONXX is working
to integrate Wi-Fi and "Open Ethernet" into
the CONXX Platform. Wi-Fi is inexpensive (if not "free"
from being built-in to systems such as laptops) and
becoming ubiquitous. A CONXX Platform Network last-mile(s)
radio would be used to link to a multi-tenant building
such as an office building, shopping mall, apartment
building, nursing home, etc. Inside that building, either
Wi-Fi Access Points (APs) or Ethernet wiring provides
a connection between the user and the CONXX Platform
Network. When the user connects their device to Wi-Fi
or Ethernet, they are presented with a choice of service
providers the first time they use their web browser.
Some service providers may offer free services (at reduced
capabilities or reduced speed or merely to present civic
information.) Other service providers can offer varying
prices and services. Still others can offer specialized
services such as Voice Over Internet Protocol (VOIP)
telephony services (getting very easy with the recent
release of VOIP over Wi-Fi "cordless" phones.)
All the described service providers can coexist in
the building... or zone (outdoor Wi-Fi technology
is evolving rapidly, especially those systems that
make use of dynamic wireless mesh network technology.)
The "Open Access One Step Further"
model extends to non-commercial service providers
such as government users. Police could use Wi-Fi Intranet
Access from a handheld computer in a mall; a public
health nurse could use a laptop in a senior citizen's
center to maintain records on her senior-citizen patients.
Wi-Fi "webcams" can be used to monitor key
traffic intersections.
All of these services are extremely cost-effective
to the user because their investment in access technology
is minimal, if not free and they have freedom of choice
in providers because of effective competition. Such
service is cost-effective to the service provider
to provide, and the CONXX Platform Network owner because
the cost of a last-mile(s) link is absorbed over multiple
end users and there is no cost to the service provider
to connect individual users.
Economic Model(s)
There are a number of potential economic
models for deployment of CONXX Platform Networks.
In Allegany County, Maryland, government entities
paid for the construction of AllCoNet2 and in return
were able to avoid enormous ongoing telecommunications
costs by "bypassing" the local telephone
company for communications between government offices
and the ability to truly competitive-source their
remaining "external" telecommunications
requirements. While those avoided costs provided the
direct cost-justification for the expense of building
AllCoNet2, the other purpose in building AllCoNet2's
was to offer cost-competitive, state-of-the-art telecommunications
services to entice companies to relocate facilities
and jobs to Allegany County, and in this, AllCoNet2
has succeeded.
The CONXX Platform is cost-effective enough to be
a "bypass" telecommunications infrastructure
for a well-established ISP or Competitive Local Exchange
Carrier who is currently using telephone company infrastructure
to connect to their customers that business
model has become somewhat precarious of late. It may
well be feasible to build a CONXX Platform Network
on a co-op model, where a number of existing ISPs
can come together to build a single network that they
could all use collectively somewhat like the Open
Access model discussed above (but restricted to use
only by those who contributed financially.) One of
the more intriguing possibilities is for CONXX Platform
Networks to be built to replace and extend existing
ISP operations in a "roll up" model, and
with the Quality Of Service inherent in the CONXX
Platform, add higher-margin services such as VOIP
from national vendors such as Vonage.
Despite its roots of being developed to solve the
Rural Digital Divide issue, the CONXX Platform is
also applicable to urban network deployments. There
are a number of urban Broadband Wireless Service Providers
operating quite successfully, but the services that
they offer are typically "best-effort".
That's because the last-mile wireless systems that
they use have no inherent ability to insure Quality
Of Service or they have no way to "couple"
the QOS capabilities in their wired infrastructure
to the QOS capabilities (if any) in their wireless
infrastructure. That is the core technical problem
that the CONXX Platform solves coupling QOS
across disparate network "layers". To be
ready for urban opportunities, CONXX is working to
incorporate wireless systems that are particularly
well-suited for urban use, such as 60 GHz license-exempt
systems, into the CONXX Platform.
Accommodating the requirements of Public Safety was
a major design goal of AllCoNet2 and the CONXX Platform.
Public safety agencies are an ideal user of CONXX
Platform Networks as the vast majority of the cost
is front-loaded into the construction of the network,
with very little ongoing Operating Expense
the same way that Public Safety agencies have historically
built and operated their networks where they want
the majority of their operational budget to go into
equipment, salaries to serve their mandate. A CONXX
Platform Network can not only provide carrier-grade,
highly-reliable "fixed" telecommunications
services, but can also supplement a public safety
agency's mobile infrastructure by extending two-way
radio services cost-effectively into new areas and
bridging multiple two-way radio systems together as
needed by transporting "Push To Talk" voice
traffic seamlessly across the network. AllCoNet2 has
integrated very cost-effective mobile broadband capabilities
to provide into additional coverage areas.
CONXX Communications Deployment
Platform
The CONXX Communications Deployment Platform
(CDP) distills the unique aspects of the CONXX Platform's
technology into a product package consisting of hardware,
software, and services. CONXX offers the CDP to enable
network builders to add cost-effective, carrier-grade
reliability to new or existing networks. The CDF consists
of three hardware units, the CONXX Network Management
System, and a hardware/software support contract.
There are two optional services available as part
of the CONXX Communications Deployment Platform
Turnkey Installation Services, and Integration / Certification
Services (for systems that are not already certified
for use with the CDP.
Conclusion
While the CONXX Platform is, at its most
simple, a Broadband Wireless Internet Access system...
it is far, far more than merely "yet another
BWIA system".
The CONXX Platform is simultaneously a well-proven
business model for next-generation telecommunications
services, a unique combination of leading-edge technologies
and the ability to accommodate legacy telecommunications
requirements. Networks such as AllCoNet2 can be one
piece of economic salvation to communities that would
otherwise be bypassed in the rush towards the global
broadband economy.
Postscripts
MSNBC, March 26, 2004
Bush calls for universal broadband by 2007
By MSNBC Staff and Reuters
ALBUQUERQUE - Reaching back to revive an idea promoted
by the man he beat for the White House, President
Bush urged Friday that affordable high-speed Internet
access be available to all Americans by 2007, saying
it was essential to the nation's economic growth.
(As this article is written, twenty-three months have
elapsed since President Bush's call for affordable,
universal broadband, with no detectable progress.
In fact, the US's position on Broadband has gotten
worse in those twenty-two months.)
Salon.com, October 18, 2005
Free American broadband!
By S. Derek Turner
In France, you can get super-fast DSL, unlimited
phone service and 100 TV channels for a mere $38 a
month. Why does the same thing cost so much more in
the U.S.?
Next time you sit down to pay your cable-modem or
DSL bill, consider this: Most Japanese consumers can
get an Internet connection that's 16 times faster
than the typical American DSL line for a mere $22
per month.
Across the globe, it's the same story. In France,
DSL service that is 10 times faster than the typical
United States connection; 100 TV channels and unlimited
telephone service cost only $38 per month. In South
Korea, super-fast connections are common for less
than $30 per month. Places as diverse as Finland,
Canada and Hong Kong all have much faster Internet
connections at a lower cost than what is available
here. In fact, since 2001, the U.S. has slipped from
fourth to 16th in the world in broadband use per capita.
While other countries are taking advantage of the
technological, business and education opportunities
of the broadband era, America remains lost in transition.
(Will the next Amazon.com, or Google, or eBay be
birthed somewhere other than the US? Some would argue
it's already happened Online gaming [as opposed
to gambling] is an enormous business worldwide, and
many of the largest such companies are not based in
the US.)
(Lafayette, Louisiana) Daily Advertiser, January
6, 2006
Appeals court blocks sale of fiber bonds
Claire Taylor
After nearly two years of planning and a public vote,
the city's efforts to bring fiber optic cable to every
home and business hit another snag Thursday.
The Third Circuit Court of Appeal ruled that Lafayette
cannot issue bonds to build the fiber-to-the-home
project under the ordinance approved by the City-Parish
Council on Sept. 6.
The ruling favors private telecommunications company
BellSouth, which has fought the plan from the beginning,
saying it represents unfair competition by the city-owned
Lafayette Utilities System. The city already has spent
more than $125,000 fighting lawsuits over the project.
Lafayette can appeal to the state supreme court or
rewrite the bond ordinance. Either way, Thursday's
decision delays the bond sale and the fiber project,
which city leaders hailed as a means to create high-tech
jobs and shrink the digital divide between residents
who can afford high-speed Internet access and those
who cannot.
"City leaders are disappointed with the decision,
and we're meeting with our legal and finance teams
to determine how to proceed with the wishes of the
voters of the city of Lafayette," City-Parish
President Joey Durel said in a statement.
Thursday's ruling reverses an earlier decision by
Fifteenth Judicial District Judge Durwood Conque that
favored LUS's fiber proposal.
LUS Director Terry Huval recently said if the appeals
court were to uphold the bond ordinance, LUS could
sell bonds in March, and the first fiber customers
could be serviced in mid-2007.
On July 16, by a vote of 12,290 to 7,507, or 62 percent
to 38 percent, city of Lafayette voters agreed to
issue up to $125 million in bonds to pay for the fiber-to-the-home
project, which would offer customers high-speed Internet,
telephone and television service. The election was
forced by a lawsuit filed by BellSouth, Cox Communications
and three citizens who argued successfully that LUS
was using an improper state law to issue the fiber
bonds. City leaders conceded and called for the election.
(Some communities such as Lafayette recognize the
need for affordable, universal broadband and are trying
to make it happen, at least for their citizens. But
when the incumbents have any kind of leverage, however
slim, they can exert influence. Also... note the figure
- $125 million! That's how much one small community
thinks it's worth to get to affordable, universal
broadband service.)
Washington Post, January 31, 2006
Ivan G. Seidenberg Interview Excerpts
By Arshad Mohammed
Q: Do you know how many hundreds, thousands
[of franchise agreements] you would need to get to
your target?
A: There are several thousand. I also need
to make this point. So this is the only threatening
comment I'll make. That over time, remember, there
are some franchises that are big. So let's take the
city of Philadelphia -- it's big. . . . So the issue
is, that's counted as one. Then you've got all these
oodles of them in the state of New Jersey, or Virginia
. . . So at some point, if we don't clean up this
process, we just won't be in a position to do all
the things that we think could be done. So at this
point I think doing it town by town . . . we are willing
to do it to prove the feasibility of why this is all
a good idea. But at some point, if we don't see some
change in behavior here, I think we are going to have
to question how much we can do and how fast we do
it.
Q: Does that mean that you will concentrate
on the big franchises rather than the little ones?
A: It means that -- we'll decide when we get
there.
(Does this portend Verizon Communications exiting
more small markets?)
MSNBC / Newsweek, January 9, 2006
We All Have a Lot To Learn
By Fareed Zakaria
Shanmugaratnam also pointed out that American universities
are unrivaled globallyand are getting better.
"You have created a public-private partnership
in tertiary education that is amazingly successful.
The government provides massive funding, and private
and public colleges compete, raising everyone's standards."
Despite all the praise Shanmugaratnam showered on
the States, he said that the U.S. educational system
"as a whole has failed." "Unless you
are comfortably middle class or richer," he explained,
"you get an education that is truly second-rate
by any standards. Apart from issues of fairness, what
this means is that you never really access the talent
of poor, bright kids. They don't go to good schools
and, because of teaching methods that focus on bringing
everyone along, the bright ones are never pushed.
In Singapore we get the poor kid who is very bright
and very hungry, and that's crucial to our success."
This sounds like a distribution problem bright
kids in the US can't gain access to the superior resources
of the US higher education system.
http://ocw.mit.edu/index.html
Welcome to MIT's OpenCourseWare:
a free and open educational resource for faculty,
students, and self-learners around the world. OCW
supports MIT's mission to advance knowledge and education,
and serve the world in the 21st century. It is true
to MIT's values of excellence, innovation, and leadership.
MIT OCW:
- Is a publication of MIT course materials
- Does not require any registration
- Is not a degree-granting or certificate-granting
activity
In January, 2006 CONXX enabled the first ISP on AllCoNet2,
making it possible for "regular customers"
to get affordable, fast, Broadband Internet Access
in more than 90% of Allegany County. In coming months
and years other ISPs will be added to AllCoNet2 and
coverage will be expanded. The quality and speed of
Broadband Internet Access via AllCoNet2 rivals most
of the "15 better Broadband Countries" cited
above. All schools in Allegany County have already
had Internet access for close to a decade.
The US has a habit of leaping ahead conceptually
from the rest of the world. A century ago an American
invented the telephone. For most of the previous century
the US had a telecommunications system that was the
envy of the world. A few decades ago the Internet
was created in the US. Perhaps this decade will see
the joining of universal, reasonable cost Broadband
Internet Access to bridge the gap between Internet-based
educational resources like OpenCourseWare and ordinary
people's kids.
Thanks to AllCoNet2, a CONXX Platform Network, the
children of Allegany County are ready for that to
happen now.
Author's Note - I'd like to
thank Earl D. Tanner, Jr. for a very careful reading
of the article and numerous suggestions that markedly
improved the overall readability of this article.
About the Author
Steve Stroh has been writing about Broadband
Wireless Internet Access since beginning a column
on the subject in Boardwatch Magazine in April, 1997.
Stroh was hired as Senior Research Analyst and CONXX
employee #3 in January, 2006. More information on
Stroh is available at www.stevestroh.com
About CONXX, Inc.
CONXX, Inc. was formed as a technology
transfer partner for the technology originally developed
for AllCoNet2, an innovative county-wide wireless
telecommunications network in Allegany County, Maryland.
The AllCoNet2 technology has been extended and updated
into the CONXX Platform. In 2006 CONXX will be building
a number additional CONXX Platform Networks for other
government entities and offer for sale a product package
derived from the AllCoNet2 technology. More information
on CONXX is available at www.conxx.net.
About
AllCoNet2
AllCoNet2 is an innovative Broadband
Wireless Access network in Allegany County, Maryland
built and funded by a partnership of government and
not-for-profit entities to provide a 21st century
telecommunications infrastructure for the citizens,
businesses, schools, and government agencies of Allegany
County. AllCoNet2 is now operated and managed by CONXX,
Inc. under contact to the founding entities. More
information about AllCoNet2 is available at www.allconet.org.
Further reading - other
Articles and Information About AllCoNet2 and CONXX,
Inc.
MICROWAVE IN MARYLAND; Rural America GOES BROADBAND,
Wireless Business Technology Magazine article, May,
2002
http://www.allconet.org/Wireless-Business-Technology.pdf
Bridging the Cumberland Gap, Telephony article, March
18, 2002 -
http://www.allconet.org/Telephony_Magazine.pdf
Western Maryland's Revolutionary WAN, Marconi Case
Study, 2003
http://www.allconet.org/Allconet_cs.pdf
Alvarion's Radios Chosen for AllCoNet2 Network, Broadband
Wireless Online article, May 10, 2004 -
http://mobileipexpo.com/magazine/print_news.asp?news=3345
Moving Beyond Wireless Broadband to Carrier Grade
Infrastructure, Presentation to WCA Conference, 2005
-
www.wcai.com/pdf/2005/05presentations/Tanner_Todd.pdf
The ATM WISP, ISP Planet article, August 9, 2005
http://www.isp-planet.com/fixed_wireless/business/2005/conxx.html
[1]Senior Research Analyst, CONXX,
Inc.
[2] There is a very interesting human
interest story that deserves to be told about how
AllCoNet2 came to be, but this particular story is
about the unique aspects of the AllCoNet2 / CONXX
Platform's technology and architecture.
[3] Because the technologies available
for future CONXX Platform networks are now starting
to diverge somewhat from the completed and operational
AllCoNet2, hereafter I will use the term CONXX Platform
almost exclusively.
[4] This article is not an attempt
to answer "if" AllCoNet2 / CONXX Platform
Networks "work". It does, most assuredly
work extremely well; AllCoNet2 is in operation 24x7x365
at 5-9's reliability, with thousands of users in Allegany
Country Maryland. This article attempts to explain
how AllCoNet2 / CONXX Platform Networks work, and
some of the design and operation rationale.
[5]It's important that I not mislead
the reader that the CONXX Platform is capable of "Plain
Old Telephone Service"... at least in the usual
sense of using individual copper wires from a central
office that ultimately connect to each individual
telephone. The CONXX Platform does offer equivalent
telephony services through the use of "Voice
Over Internet Protocol" (VOIP) via wireless links
(as the equivalent of the copper wires) and a unit
called an Analog Telephone Adapter (ATA) to allow
a conventional telephone to continue to be used. In
the end, one can use VOIP and an ATA allows the use
of conventional telephones, used in a conventional
manner, with the same degree of reliability (with
the exception that [I think] rotary dial phones cannot
be used to initiate calls when connected to an ATA.)
|